The tradition of the elderly female detective dates back nearly as long as mystery novels themselves. Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple and television’s Jessica Fletcher have delighted readers and audiences for years. Veteran author Simon Brett, a master of the cozy mystery, has his own practitioner of the subgenre, Mrs Pargeter. Like Marple, Fletcher, and various other female sleuths, Mrs Pargeter solves murder mysteries. However, she’s got some help the others don’t. It seems the late Mr Pargeter was a clever lawbreaker, unknown to his wife. His parting gift to her, along with a sizable inheritance that left her well fixed enough to engage in amateur detection, was a little black book containing a seemingly endless list of Mr Pargeter’s former criminal companions willing to help her. Mrs Pargeter’s Past, the newest novel in the long-running series, varies the usual formula to some extent, but it still exerts its comic charms for readers.
Mrs Pargeter’s Past is not a cozy mystery in the traditional sense. It might best be described as a “cozy crime thriller,” if such a term exists. The story begins with “Short Head” Shimmings, a bookmaker acquaintance of Mr Pargeter, coming to Mrs Pargeter for help. Short Head (so named because the horses he bet on tended to lose by a short head) is a bookie with a bad gambling
problem of his own. He owes a pair of local mobsters, the Batinga brothers, a lot of money, and they intend to kill him to make a point about what happens to those who welsh on their debts to the brothers. Mrs Pargeter offers her help, which begins by finding a safe house for Short Head while she figures out how to put the Batinga brothers out of business.
The unfortunate bookie’s nickname, Short Head, is just one of the many delights for readers of Mrs Pargeter’s Past. Mr Pargeter’s criminal associates all have colorful nicknames, some of which are explained in the book, like “Hedgeclipper” Clinton, “Truffler” Mason, “Derek the Draft,” “Holy” Smirke, and “Jukebox” Jarvis (Mr Pargeter’s former accountant, so named because he kept all the records). Those acquaintances are all quite good at what they do, and the first section of the book resembles an escapade straight out of a Mission: Impossible movie, as they find a hiding place for Short Head and his mother (he won’t travel without her) in an apartment buried deep underneath Holy Smirke’s church (he is an actual minister).
Once Short Head is safe, Mrs Pargeter can turn to the business at hand. At this point, a large part of “Mrs Pargeter’s Past” comprises flashback scenes from thirty years earlier, when the Pargeters were first married. Longtime fans of the series will note that this section marks readers’ first encounter with the late Mr Pargeter while he was alive and shows his sweet infatuation with his wife. The flashbacks also reveal that Mr Pargeter was a considerably more important gangster than earlier books in the series might lead readers to believe. While having dinner with his wife, Mr Pargeter butts heads with the younger Batinga brothers, who introduce themselves as the Smith brothers. Much later in the book, Mrs Pargeter realizes that the present-day Batinga brothers are the same Smith brothers she met thirty years earlier.
The Mrs Pargeter books require a huge suspension of disbelief from readers. Mrs Pargeter is supposedly completely ignorant of her husband’s illicit activities, an obtuseness I found especially hard to accept given the criminal goings-on in Mrs Pargeter’s Past. (At one point, Mr Pargeter refers to getting in a turf war with the Smith Brothers, which his wife interprets to mean a dispute over landscaping.) Mrs Pargeter’s charms, being completely in the dark about her husband’s criminality while witnessing several crimes committed around her, were somewhat hard for me to accept.
The Batinga brothers also seemed out of place in this type of book. The older Batinga brother has had a romantic crush on Mrs Pargeter for thirty years, since they first met. However, the younger one is a psychopath who enjoys torturing people to get information, especially when he doesn’t get enough sleep. His threats of violence against various characters, including Mrs Pargeter, are quite credible, leading to a finale that seems more appropriate in a traditional crime thriller than in a cozy story like Mrs Pargeter’s Past.
I learned something about British life from reading Mrs Pargeter’s Past that I never knew before: the tradition of the livery company. For those like me who live on this side of the pond, a livery company is a trade guild that, at least in this story, has rituals and traditions similar to those of American fraternal societies. Mrs Pargeter and the older Batinga brother attend one of their ceremonies in one of the book’s pivotal (and more entertaining) sequences.
Mrs Pargeter’s Past represents my first encounter with Mrs Pargeter and her colorful associates. I did research on the character after I read the book to get a better background before writing this review. However, knowledge of the earlier books in the series isn’t essential for readers to enjoy the current story. I can’t compare Mrs Pargeter’s Past to those earlier novels, and I didn’t feel the same thrill some readers might at finally meeting Mr Pargeter. However, I enjoyed the colorful nicknames, the author’s wit, and Mrs Pargeter’s character. I wasn’t able to fully suspend my disbelief, and some events here were a bit too silly. Nonetheless, the book’s charms outweighed my occasional discomfort. For fans of this series or cozy mysteries in general, Mrs Pargeter’s Past should be in those readers’ presents.
NOTE: The publisher graciously provided me with a copy of this book through NetGalley. However, the decision to review the book and the contents of this review are entirely my own.
In this clip, author Simon Brett discusses his writing career on the Listening Books podcast:
Read other reviews of Mrs Pargeter's Past:
Simon Brett is a British author of detective fiction, a playwright, and a producer-writer for television and radio. After his graduation from Oxford University, Brett joined the BBC as a trainee and worked for BBC Radio and London Weekend Television. While with the BBC, Brett produced the pilot episode of The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy, as well as many episodes of the comedy series The Burkiss Way, He also produced the comedy panel games I'm Sorry I Haven't a Clue and Just a Minute and radio adaptations of Lord Peter Wimsey works.
As an author, Brett has written over 100 books. He is best known for his mystery series featuring second-rate character actor Charles Paris, beginning with Cast, in Order of Disappearance in 1975. He has also written 22 novels in the Fethering series featuring amateur sleuths Carole Seldon and Jude, who reside in that town. Brett has also written several stand-alone novels, including A Shock to the System, which was adapted into a movie starring Michael Caine. Mrs Pargeter, Fethering, and Blotto & Twinks.Brett has written five series of detective novels. Most of Brett’s series novels are in the "Golden Age" tradition of detective fiction, featuring fair play, intricate plot twists, and eccentric characters.
In 2014, Brett was chosen as the recipient of the Cartier Diamond Dagger from the Crime Writers' Association for "an outstanding body of work in crime fiction." He is also a member of the Detection Club and served as its President from 2000 until 2015.
Header Photo: "Riot Radio" by Arielle Calderon / Flickr / CC By / Cropped
Silver Screen Video Banner Photos: pedrojperez / Morguefile; wintersixfour / Morguefile
Join Button: "Film Element" by Stockphotosforfree
Twitter Icon: "Twitter Icon" by Freepik
Facebook Icon: "Facebook Icon" by Freepik
LinkedIn Icon: "LinkedIn Icon" by Fathema Khanom / Freepik
Goodreads Icon: "Letter G Icon" by arnikahossain / Freepik
Simon Brett: "Simon Brett" (cropped) by annie_c_2 / Flickr / CC BY-NC-ND 2.0
Certain images on this site appear courtesy of Amazon.com and other sponsors of Silver Screen Videos for the purpose of advertising products on those sites. Silver Screen Videos earns commissions from purchases on those sites.
© 2026 Steven R. Silver. All rights reserved.







